A Philosophical Dialogue on Virtue, Divine Will, and Human Moral Agency: Perspectives from Plato, Aristotle, and Augustine
Overview
This paper presents a dialogue-based philosophical exploration of virtue ethics and the source of human moral virtue through conversations between the narrator and three historical philosophers: Plato, Aristotle, and Augustine. The discussion centers on whether virtues are divinely bestowed or derived from human agency, examining competing theological and philosophical perspectives on human nature and moral obligation.
What this essay covers
- Introduction and Setup: The narrator embarks on a journey with three philosophers, initiating discussion on the nature of humanity and virtue
- Augustine's Theological Perspective: Virtues as divine gifts and the fallen nature of man requiring God's grace
- Plato's Dualistic View: The separation of body and soul, with the soul as the nobler entity responsible for moral decisions
- Aristotle's Humanistic Approach: Virtue as individual moral obligation independent of divine attribution, grounded in reason and science
Preview
Student
Instructor
Course
Philosophy Dialogue With Plato, Aristotle, and Augustine
I walk with Plato, Aristotle, and Augustine towards the car park. As we walk, the three old men appear to seem to be cheerful and all merry. It is almost the new year, and the weather in tropical countries like it is very warm. We are on our journey to Mt. Kenya. We will be taking a three-day hike until we reach the peak of the mountain. As I ponder what we should do on our way to Mt. Kenya, I decide to start a conversation about key philosophical issues affecting our scout. Before the driver could enter the car, every person requests a bottle of water. Probably they sensed that they would talk for long as we head to Mt. Kenya. Since I was the driver, I decided to make the sharing exciting and somewhat philosophical. There are many things I wanted to learn about philosophy, and I figured this is an opportune moment to learn from Plato, Aristotle, and Augustine.
Me: (After starting the car) Without a doubt, I believe that I only have humans on board.
(Deep sighs are heard from the seats behind, probably, the three were considering what I meant by the statement. Plato breaks the silence)
Plato: As long as all of us have certain qualities, we cannot assume that we are all humans.
Augustine: Yes, I agree with you. Humans must possess certain virtues, which I believe are given by God.